Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

It is easy to apply on lids;
The color is intense;
It doesn't smudge;
It lasts long;
It can be too black and make your eyes look dramatic. Better for evening makeup looks.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

What I especially love about this liner is though it doesn't smudge or run (it says waterproof and it means it), when I took it off (the next morning mind you) with my face wipes, it came off super easily. My other long wearing liners take a good scrubbing which is very irritating to the sensitive skin around the eye.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

This is the first liquid eyeliner I've ever used. My eyeliner tends to end up in the crease so I've only used a gel eyeliner for the past few years. That got kind of old, having to use the eyeliner brush, wash it after every use, etc. This liquid eyeliner makes it so much easier, and it stays put. It's easy to use, dries quickly, but if you make a mistake it's easy to clean up with a Qtip and makeup remover. A friend recommended it to me & I'm glad I listened. I would definitely buy this again.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

Love, Love, Love this eyeliner. Highly recommend it. Stays on all day.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

Best liquid eyeliner I've used. I am not sure I would buy it again as I now preffer cream liner much better.
On this, the very thin pen allows you to do perfect cat eyes & just gives you a lot of control & lasts if you use primer, without primer, not so much, your cat eye lines on the side of your eyes can become smudges after about 2 hours, it also seemed to wear off rather quick near the tear ducts.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

I'm so bummed about this eyeliner. I'm sad because I love it! However, after a while (maybe 4-6 weeks MAX), the felt tip doesn't hold its shape and the color really fades.

It lasts just fine on my eyes, just not so much in the packaging. I don't know if it dries up too quickly or what, but the color eventually goes on in a faded-out version of what it was in the first few weeks.

It's a shame because it's a wonderful product while it lasts. Hopefully Stila will redesign the packaging so eyeliner lasts longer.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

First, I hate writing reviews. This one deserves my time. It's easy to use and effective. I use it to line my lids but also to tightline, which I why I bought it. I was a hoping a waterproof, pen-like liner would do the trick. And it does. I only wish it were half the cost; however I do recommend it and will repurchase.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

I needed a new eye liner and was in a department store and asked one of the sale associates which brand had a good liquid liner that goes on dark, doesn't run and stays on all day. She recommended Stila. I was iffy at first because I'm used to using a liquid that comes in like a well where as this is like using s pen. But I love it. Its easy to put on. Love the fact that it goes on dark in one application I go over the line two times but that's because i like a dark bold look.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

I love defining my eyes, but at my age (50+), wearing eyeliner has to look just right beneath my eyeglasses or I end up looking overmade, owl-eyed or even worse, older! I read all the other reviews and decided to give Stila a shot. It is well worth the money! It goes on super easy even for someone as clumsy as me, lasts all day, and looks great with or without eyeshadow! I use a good eye-makeup remover to take it off at night, but it comes off without any problems. I am so glad I discovered this product and recommend it to anyone looking for an easy-to-use eyeliner with staying power.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Black, .01 fl oz:

I really liked this liquid liner when I first used it. The applicator was nice and firm so it was easy to work with. However, after a week or so the ink wasn't flowing as fluidly. After a month the tip started to loose it's shape making it difficult to apply. I used it everyday, so maybe if you want it for the occasional eyeliner it would last longer. For the price, I was hoping it would hold up better.