Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Moss, .01 oz:

This is a great long lasting eyeliner on the first use. After the first use the tip is dry which is a waste of money for me. The best eyeliner is Urban Decay's 24/7. It's amazing. Better than MACs eyeliner too. :)

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Moss, .01 oz:

I bought the green (moss) eyeliner on a whim at a retail store and loved it so much that I've now purchased 3 additional colors: brown, blue and gray.

First & foremost, this product dries QUICKLY. I didn't have to wait around for my lids to dry before moving on with my makeup routine. Second, the long pointy applicator tip equals an easy, smooth, well-defined line. (But these 2 factors combined mean if you mess up, your only option is a q-tip, eyemakeup remover, and do over.) Third, it is MOSTLY waterproof **IF** you use an eyeshadow primer FIRST. When I skip the primer, the liner will smudge and run a bit; but with the primer, it lasts all day, even through a gym workout (it may flake a little in the shower but mostly stays put...although means its tougher than most eyeliners to remove - just use a qtip or ongoing gentle rubbing.)

I apply the eyeliner, then apply a layer of shadow for a more smudged look. I also store the tubes vertically with pointy end down so that they're less likely to dry out. Have had NO issues with clumping after several weeks.

Comments on the colors/quality, b/c there are some differences:
MOSS-my fave, dark green color, stays put, easiest to remove
INDIGO-boldest color so best for going out, ok to remove
ALLOY-lighter than expected, runs some, least favorite
DARK BROWN-excellent, stays put, hardest to remove

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Moss, .01 oz:

Besides not being waterproof, the product felt sticky on my eyelids after it dried.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Moss, .01 oz:

I bought three different colors, used them once or twice and on the third use, they were clumpy, did not run smooth. They were capped properly after each use. Poor product.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Moss, .01 oz:

I was a little afraid of the color (I purchased Moss), but it is actually very wearable, deep green. You have to look very closely to see that it is green, but it sparks up my green eyes. Super easy to apply - the tiny point can be used to make a thin line, or you can slant the tube slightly and use the side of the applicator to make a thicker line. Just shake it up before you use it. I store it upright just to make sure it doesn't leak, and make sure I snap the cap on tightly after use. Stays on all day and washes off completely with face wash.

Comments about Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Moss, .01 oz:

It is not visibly green (moss colored). I was hoping for a bit more green. The applicator doesn't always work as it is spring loaded? Makes a nice fine line, though,